The Perfect Society!

 A WebQuest on The Giver: A Novel by Lois Lowry

 

Journal | Student | Teacher

 

The Committee's Individual Reports

 (25 points)

 

Aspect of work

 

Weak (0-1 point)

 

Fair (2-3 points)

 

Perfect (4-5 points)

 

 

Question and answer interview of one of the members of the community who had contact with Jonas

 

 

Only five of the questions were answered. The student has not developed the ideas in the assignment.

 

Eight of the questions were answered. The student has selected and developed an idea but has not supported that idea. Details are inappropriate and/or logic is faulty.

 

 

All ten of the questions were answered. The student has selected and developed ideas and has supported those ideas with logic and/or appropriate details.
 

 

Findings

 

No findings stated

 

One or two findings  stated

 

 

Three or four findings clearly stated and supported with logic and appropriate details

 

 

Suggestions

 

Only one or two  suggestions made without detail or evidence of critical thinking or problem-solving skills

 

 

Only three suggestions were made. The suggestions showed some evidence of critical thinking and problem-solving skills.

 

 

More than four suggestions made

all of which demonstrated clear evidence of critical thinking and problem-solving skills.
 

 

Organization

 

The student has not demonstrated an understanding of paragraph structure, transitions, or unity.
 

 

The student has written with good overall structure and unity. There is weakness in one of the following criteria: organized paragraphs or smooth transitions.
 

 

The student has organized ideas into coherent paragraphs with smooth transitions. The assignment has good structure and unity.
 

 

Accuracy

 

 

Many grammar mistakes

 

Only one or two grammar mistakes

 

 

No grammar mistakes

Last updated January 23, 2006 by Nellie Deutsch with suggestions by Sharon Peters