The Perfect Society!
A WebQuest on The Giver: A Novel by Lois Lowry
The Committee's Individual Reports
(25 points)
Aspect of work |
Weak (0-1 point) |
Fair (2-3 points) |
Perfect (4-5 points)
|
Question and answer interview of one of the members of the community who had contact with Jonas
|
Only five of the questions were answered. The student has not developed the ideas in the assignment. |
Eight of the questions were answered. The student has selected and developed an idea but has not supported that idea. Details are inappropriate and/or logic is faulty.
|
All ten of the questions were
answered. The student has selected and developed ideas and has
supported those ideas with logic and/or appropriate details. |
Findings |
No findings stated |
One or two findings stated
|
Three or four findings clearly stated and supported with logic and appropriate details
|
Suggestions |
Only one or two suggestions made without detail or evidence of critical thinking or problem-solving skills
|
Only three suggestions were made. The suggestions showed some evidence of critical thinking and problem-solving skills.
|
More than four suggestions made
all of which
demonstrated clear evidence of critical thinking and
problem-solving skills. |
Organization |
The student has not demonstrated an understanding of paragraph
structure, transitions, or unity. |
The student has written with good overall structure and unity.
There is weakness in one of the following criteria: organized
paragraphs or smooth transitions. |
The student has organized ideas into coherent paragraphs with
smooth transitions. The assignment has good structure and unity. |
Accuracy
|
Many grammar mistakes |
Only one or two grammar mistakes
|
No grammar mistakes |
Last updated January 23, 2006 by Nellie Deutsch with suggestions by Sharon Peters